Altar Your Life

Altar Your Life

Friday, November 11, 2005

To Make the World Safe for Democracy?

Woodrow Wilson was really an idealist. Not that I'm against idealism, but one must reckon with one's own idealism, knowing what virtue it intends as its goal. Wilson, of course, was a Princeton, Enlightenment scholar. His "common good," I daresay, is not the same common good I strive towards. I, for one, see the common good as eternal communion with the virtue - God, who is "The Good". Well, anyway, democracy is not the eschatological hope. It is not that place where "we cast our crowns before thee, lost in wonder, love, and praise" (to coin a great Wesley hymn). So why am I going on about this? I watched Jarhead last night. My good friends, Bo and Bud, were with me. It is a disturbing look at the psychological effects of military conditioning. What happens, the movie begs, when one is programmed to kill, to be ok with killing, and to want to kill, but is denied the opportunity to kill? These young marines are trained, nay, re-programmed to desire killing, almost as a sexual release. There is a very telling scene when the marines are gathered to watch a scene from "Apocolypse Now." It's the scene when the helicopters are coming into the Vietnamese village to lay it waste. Civilian Vietnamese people (many children) are slaughtered on screne. The marines yell and screme at the movie they are watching, not in horror, but in eager anticipation. It's almost orgiastic. The main character in the film expresses on his face the look of a man caught up in the ecstasy of sex as he watches people being gunned down. This is what the marine corps did to these young men. It made them into killing machines who craved death. But, the conflict in the film is that they are denied their orgasm. The main character is trained as a sniper and goes to the Persian Gulf (Gulf War I). However, he never fires a shot. He almost gets to kill someone, but is denied that pleasure. The end of the war shows marines dancing and partying around a giant fire in the desert, shooting their guns into the air - shooting at nothing. It's ironic. They shoot. This is what they are supposed to do, what they are formed to do, yet they shoot at nothing. Ultimately, this is not the release they desire. They want to kill, but they can't. The death is inside themselves. Very disturbing, especially since I have a brother in the Marine Corps.

4 comments:

Bo the Fat said...

Barry, i think you are right to employ the sexual imagery...in the end, i think that was what the director was going for visually.

what i wonder is how the marines are different now to what they where say in WWII. i was talking to my mom about my grandad, who never talked about the war, but when he was really sick shortly before he died, he said things like "although i wouldn't change a thing, i would never ask anyone, from any country, to kill another person." it drove him to drinking, and it made him struggle his whole life with whether his country asked too much of him when they asked him to take the lives of other people.

now, in the context of this movie, what does it mean for the main character to say "we are always in the desert." i wonder if it would mean the same thing to say that my grandad was always "in the pacific islands." like the movie says. every war is different, every war is the same...

oh, and just a piddly annoying note, God isn't a virtue...a virtue is a habit, so God would probably better be called the end of all virtue...although if God is love(charity), and charity is the form of the virtues, you probably could say that. it just rolls of the tongue wierd. maybe you could say that, God, the form of all virtues. anyway, just thinking on screen

Barry "der schwertfechter" Bennett said...

Actually, Bo, that's exactly what I mean by "the virtue." It's a Wesley thing. Oftentimes in the hymns he refers dually to love and God as "the virtue." So, yes, when I speak of God as love, and charity as the form of all the virtues, I mean God as "the virtue." It's straight from Wesley.

Barry "der schwertfechter" Bennett said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Thunder Jones said...

Should I go see it?

Bo, you're so pleasant on this blog... and no cursing!

One Love